[identity profile] peggy-2.livejournal.com posting in [community profile] queensthief
How about an Opera of The Thief?  Or even better, the Queen of Attolia?

http://neil-gaiman.tumblr.com/post/18172868256/eno-announces-mini-operas-a-worldwide-online-talent

Any suggestions from the Oh So Fertile Sounis Bunch? Script? Songs? Score?   Have at it, Sounisians!


Date: 2/26/12 06:28 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] ricardienne.livejournal.com
QoA would make an excellent baroque opera! (Gen would be a countertenor, of course, and probably Nahuseresh would be the Evil Baritone). For the purposes of the opera, Gen would probably be sneaking into the palace just to see Attolia, and the political plot would have to be seriously subordinated to the romantic one. We might need to add some extra convolution, in fact, with, say, Phresine in love with Nahusersh's manservant (you know, the comic servant-romance sideplot). Attolia would get beautifully intricate agonized recitatives about what to do about Gen, and Gen would have a long convoluted aria about the fact that he's in love with the woman who cut off his hand, until Eddis -- here more or less subsuming the roles of the Magus and the Minister of War to play the operatic role of the wise parent-figure sets him straight. Then he sets off, heroically returns, he and Attolia defeat Nahuseresh, and the two of them proclaim their love with a big chorus of grateful/celebratory subjects.

Date: 2/26/12 06:56 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] helle-d.livejournal.com
Ooh, I LIKE this - I can totally imagine a delightfully convoluted and Baroque QoA opera.With extra convultion for good measure.

Date: 2/27/12 04:01 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] rosaleeluann.livejournal.com
(completely random and unrelated to the topic, but the quote on your icon thingy reminded me--what if thats ironic foreshadowing and Costis DOES become politically important, and would have been a great loss, politically speaking? Which I think would be awesome because Costis is awesome. That is all.)

Date: 2/26/12 06:53 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] helle-d.livejournal.com
In procaination from the large amount of work I should be doing, I've had a go at roughing out a possible opera plot for a (modernish opera of) QoA. It started out with Themes and songs that would be Ironically Reprised later, but as it went on, I just got buried by how much goes on in the book, even if you pare it down to the essentials. I went for the whole 'personal drama played out in front of grand scale political events' type structure, but I think to be stageable, it would need to be pared down even further, leaving out the political considerations and just sticking with the love plot.

Overture:
Begins with theme for Attolian nation. As it progresses, we see the Thief’s attempt to escape his pursuers in mime. The music becomes more heightened and dramatic, culminating in Gen being captured and imprisoned. Second movement of overture – shift to melancholy, wistful sound. We see the Queen of Attolia, standing proud and alone, at the other end of the stage from where Gen is imprisoned.
Act 1:
Crowd song – chorus between ladies of the court and soldiers giving exposition about the terrible, daring Thief of Eddis, who stole Hiamathes’ Gift and posed such a danger to their queen. They jubilate in his capture but worry about Eddis’s reaction.
Entrance of Attolia.
Attolia – aria about how as a woman ruler, she needs to be cruel and subordinate her emotions to the good of her kingdom.
Entrance of Ambassadors from Eddis and the Mede Empire. Trio, in which Ornon provokes Attolia and Nathueresh shows his influence over her as she decides not to kill Gen. The chorus comment on the power of the Mede Empire.
Aria – Gen in prison. ‘O my God, if you will not save me, make me less afraid.’ Sets up theme of faith and religion, show Gen’s fear and near-despair.
Arrival of Attolia and guards. Duet, setting up the relationship between them. Gen cannot resist taunting about what a brilliant thief he was. Gen: I was the thief in the night. I was the watcher who crept through your palaces. I can steal anything! Attolia points out that he is in her power now. Attolia: You cannot steal the chains, nor steal yourself from my walls. You cannot steal yourself. Gen: Neither can you.
Attolia sings (to herself?) that the punishment for thieves was the loss of a hand, and that she will do what she must. Gen gets his hand chopped off – instrumental?
End of Act 1.

Date: 2/26/12 06:54 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] helle-d.livejournal.com
Act 2 begins with soldiers bringing Gen up the mountain to the capital of Eddis – has the air of a funeral cortege, as the Eddisians sing a mournful dirge ‘The Thief of Eddis is returned to us’.
Arrival of Eddis. The set-up of her court shown to be in contrast to Attolia’s – unlike the lowland queen, she is supported by her various ministers/cousins, not left in isolation. Everyone angered and grieved by Gen’s condition.
Scene – Eddis and various Attolian soldiers/ambassadors/messengers, coming in succession – showing Eddis ordering the trade caravans confiscated, the Attolian response and the escalation of threats on both sides – culminating in Eddis’ ”War, then.”
Chorus – the country begins preparing for war, but everyone is still worried about Gen.
Act 3 – Gen and his massive angst. What can he steal one-handed? He is crippled and in pain, and for the first time in his life, he doubts his abilities and his gods. Attolia gets two scenes interwoven with Gen’s – in one she interacts with the court and Nathuseresth, but sings in soliloquy how she cannot stop feeling guilty over Gen’s maiming. She wonders what he meant when he said that she can’t steal herself, either. Remembers how young and helpless he looked. In her second appearance, she takes up the theme again, but remembers herself, when she was young and helpless. Heartbreaking Exposition Aria about how she came to poison her bridegroom and take the throne.
Act 4 – Lots of action in this one. Gen and companions go to Attolia to do something to stop the war. The boat/stairs scene follows the books fairly closely, as Gen declares his love. She tells him that when she wears his earrings, she will marry him willingly – not before. Ends in arrival of the Mede and Gen’s re-capture.
Act 5 – Begins with Attolia and Nahuseresh enthroned. Courtiers, soldiers of both Attolia and Mede (but rather more of the latter…) and captured Eddisians before them. She sings that she must do what is best for her country, and asks the Eddisians (including Gen?) to take their queen her message. They (and the audience) get the message. Nathuseresh does not.
Scene with Attolia and Nathuseresh watching the battle. Again, follows the book fairly closely as Attolia displays how awesome she is, and narrates what is happening in the battle.
Attolia and Eddis meet for the first time and are awesome together. In their duet, we see the contrast in their approaches as Attolia starts to unbend and show her vulnerability.
Gen and Attolia. Unheard by each other, she wonders how he could love her and he sings about how much he loves her and wants to break through the walls she’s erected. They slowly come together and admit their love. I've no idea really about how it should end.

Date: 2/26/12 07:50 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] ladraove.livejournal.com
.....This was absolutely brilliant. I want it to exist so much. SO MUCH.

Date: 2/27/12 12:10 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] 1221bookworm.livejournal.com
Wow!! I would definetly go to an operetic version of QoA!! Especially this version!! This was wonderfully thought out and filled - in. You managed to get a lot of the plot in, without leaving out all of the politics.

They (and the audience) get the message. Nathuseresh does not.


( I didn't either, the first time I read it ...)

Gen should have a deep base voice. It would do the sad parts really well. Or a baritone would do, not quite so heavy... And Nahuseresh definetly has a squeaky tenor... an annoying voice to go with his slimey personality (apologies to those who like tenors, they aren't my style :)

Date: 2/27/12 01:56 am (UTC)
ext_46111: Photo of a lady in Renaissance costume, pointing to a quote from Hamlet:  "Words, words, words". (Default)
From: [identity profile] msmcknittington.livejournal.com
I think it should probably end with the scene with Gen sacrificing the goat and speaking to the goddess (Was it Moira? I can't remember.), with Attolia waiting for him outside the doors. Which means that possibly the duet between Attolia and Eddis could end with Attolia revealing it was the gods who told her how to catch Gen? And Gen overhearing? So he storms off to summon the gods, and sings his piece about not being willing to sacrifice anything he has now to get his hand back, and Attolia is out in the hall, not knowing and longing and openly doubting, and then all the windows burst, and the door opens, and they come together.

In my opinion, that is, but I have a musical mind, not operatic one, so in my head it has a lot of, um, humor. Which is hard, because everyone knows KoA is the funny book. :P

ETA: And now I'm imagining Gen as Figaro (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Largo_al_factotum). Agh! "Make way for me! I'm Eugenides!" Maybe The Thief could be opera buffa?
Edited Date: 2/27/12 02:08 am (UTC)

Date: 2/28/12 12:37 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] agh-4.livejournal.com
Whoa, this is amazing. I can totally see it (although not completely totally, unfortunately, since it just exists here)! And the story works really well even without the Magus & co.

Date: 2/28/12 03:46 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] agh-4.livejournal.com
Stupid italics! :S

Date: 2/27/12 01:24 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] checkers65477.livejournal.com
But wait! Gen can't carry a tune, remember? Whatever will we do?

Date: 2/27/12 01:35 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] booksrgood4u.livejournal.com
Haha, but ballet would create a problem when you got to KoA - Costis doesn't seem to me to be the graceful type!
Edited Date: 2/27/12 01:36 pm (UTC)

Date: 2/27/12 06:50 pm (UTC)
From: (Anonymous)
BALLET?? *imagines Gen in a leotard*

Date: 2/27/12 08:23 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] theorangethief.livejournal.com
I would definitly go see a ballet based on QoA! *wishes it existed*

Date: 2/29/12 02:37 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] agh-4.livejournal.com
Could he rap, do you think?

Date: 3/1/12 12:56 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] checkers65477.livejournal.com
Gen could totally rap, yo.

Date: 2/27/12 09:03 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] ekachan.livejournal.com
A little visual inspiration for a QoA opera? This was a promotional image for Opera Lyra's Turandot, an opera about a ruthless queen ;).

Image

Date: 2/27/12 11:26 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] aged-crone.livejournal.com
For those who aren't as opera-educated, and just in case we want to broaden the appeal a bit, perhaps we could steal (wouldn't that be appropriate) some music and present

THE THIEF OF EDDIS

Attolia:
In sleep he slipped into
My room so dim
Those earrings by my bed
Were left by him

And do I dream again?
In shadowed gloom
The Thie-ie-ief of E-eddis* seems there *(sounds better as Eedis than Eddis)
Inside my room

Eugenides:
Play once again with me
at cat and mouse
As I slip silently
Throughout your house

And though you turn from me
To glance behind
Eugenides, Eugenides is there
Inside your mind

Attolia:
Those who have seen my face
Draw back in fear
It is a mask I wear

Eugenides:
To me it's clear

Both:
And though/since you've/I've chopped my/your hand
And made me/you ill
I know that it's quite possible/impossible that I/you
Can/can't love you/me still

Offstage voices:
He's there, the Thie-ie-ief of E-eddis...
Beware the Thie-ie-ief of E-eddis...

Eugenides:
In all your fantasies
You surely knew
Those ruby ea-earrings

Attolia:
Were brought by you

BOTH:
And in this labyrinth
Great-grandpa built
The Thie-ie-ief of E-edis
is there beside your quilt (see? See? I'm a poetic *genius*!)

Reign, my Queen of Attolia!

Attolia:
He's there,
the Thie-ie-ief of E-eddis . .
Edited Date: 2/27/12 11:28 pm (UTC)

Date: 2/27/12 11:48 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] booksrgood4u.livejournal.com
Oh My Goodness. That was too funny! I love the Phantom of the Opera!! I'm going to sing like Christine someday. *nods*

Yes, you are a poetic genius - Great job!!

Date: 2/28/12 12:27 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] 1221bookworm.livejournal.com
WOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

That fit the music PERFECTLY!!!!!!!

The Phantom is one of my favorite musicals/operas *cues playing air piano*

GREAT JOB!!! :)

Date: 2/28/12 12:35 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] agh-4.livejournal.com
BRILLIANT! AWESOME! AMAZING! :D

In this labyrinth Great-grandpa build!

Date: 2/28/12 12:58 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] 1221bookworm.livejournal.com
You should post this on the fanfic site!! Save it for generations of Sounisians!!

Date: 2/29/12 02:06 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] checkers65477.livejournal.com
I had perfect faith, Leslie, that this would be right up your alley. Bravo!!!
Page generated Jan. 21st, 2026 04:44 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios