[identity profile] tearoha.livejournal.com

Hi, *pokes head around corner, with sheepish grin* Newbie butting in again  -

So I lent my copy of The Thief to my middle little brother last week, and he just came into my room after finishing, all punch-drunk from its sheer awesomeness to talk about it with me. (Another obsessed fan on the horizon!) So we were nattering on and on about it and I mentioned something about the part in Thief where Gen does NOT die under the cliffs. And immediately, MLB goes, 'yeah, because he's got the thing in his hair that keeps him alive.'
Which made me feel, I don't know, really, REEEEALLY incredibly slow? Because I've been reading the first two books at least twice a year for at least seven years now and only realised the significance of Gen not dying after reading about it on Sounis? Also, MLB is TEN YEARS OLD and picked it up right away???

So... my question, or discussion, or whatever, is this:
1. What parts of the books took everyone a long time to 'get'? Or that you think you should have got sooner? I'm really, really hoping I'm not the only one who was this phenomenally slow, but the books are so intricate and rely such a lot on subtext as well there must have been things that other people missed...

2. Conversely, some subtext you did pick up, and remembered? (For me, realising Gen was in the room when Attolia is 'being silent' after she sentences Relius was a very, very exciting moment XD)

Thoughts?

Also, on a completely unrelated note, I was trawling throught the archives and found some references to a letter with questions sent to MWT and answered. Is there any way I can find out what was in the letter and reply?

-Te Aroha

(edited for being even more unobservant than usual: There was a lot of talk about not noticing Gen's gift-bump in Thief a few entries down which I totally missed. Gah. Other things XD?)
[identity profile] idiosyncreant.livejournal.com

I know--the While She Knits posts have become more "occasional" than bi-weekly. Part of this is Fridays are no longer a good blogging day for me, the other part...

Well, I don't like it when there are as many OT posts as there are ones on the books!
It's probably time to do something to reintroduce ourselves, or make up a contest or something. But for today, here's my ON topic While She Knits query:

What are your "prophecies" about coming books in the series? Hopes? Random plot-bunnies?

 
and if you must, Add One Non-MWT book prophecy/hope/plot bunny to your list.
Since so many of us have read the same books outside, since we've done so much recommendation swap, that should prove fun.


[For example: Does the Magus get heart-broken when Eddis marries Sophos for love & politics? Does Sophos come back from the dead, having escaped a captive engagement to a pirate queen who rescued him from the Sounisian guerrillas? Does Cassandra Mortmain in "I Capture the Castle" ever hook up with Simon?]

[identity profile] philia-fan.livejournal.com
So...here's a discussion question for fun:  Who is your favorite MINOR character in the books, and why?  Or, which minor character would you like to know more about?

Have at it.
[identity profile] peggy-2.livejournal.com

What are the Community theories surrounding Heiro's visit to Gen after his attack by the assassins and before the nightmare?  When I first read it, I assumed she brought the quinalums, at Gen's request, so he could spike his own lethium.  Now I'm not so sure.  What else might they have discussed?


And later, the queen accepts Petrus, the court physician, did not spike the lethium.  After the Dr leaves:

"You trust him?" she asked. ...
"I know something you don't," the king told her.
"Who put the quinalums in the lethium?"
"That too."

"that too" - What else does Gen know besides who put the quinalums in the lethium???

Page generated Aug. 2nd, 2025 06:16 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios